Extensive cellular heterogeneity of X inactivation revealed by single-cell allele-specific expression in human fibroblasts

ABSTRACT In eutherian mammals, X chromosome inactivation (XCI) provides a dosage compensation mechanism where in each female cell one of the two X chromosomes is randomly silenced. However, some genes on the inactive X chromosome and outside the pseudoautosomal regions escape from XCI and are expressed from both alleles (escapees). Given the relevance of the escapees in biology and medicine, we investigated XCI at an unprecedented single-cell resolution. We combined deep single-cell RNA sequencing with whole genome sequencing to examine allelic specific expression (ASE) in 935 primary fibroblast and 48 lymphoblastoid single cells from five female individuals. In this framework we integrated an original method to identify and exclude doublets of cells. We have identified 55 genes as escapees including 5 novel escapee genes. Moreover, we observed that all genes exhibit a variable propensity to escape XCI in each cell and cell type, and that each cell displays a distinct expression profile of the escapee genes. We devised a novel metric, the Inactivation Score (IS), defined as the mean of the allelic expression profiles of the escapees per cell, and discovered a heterogeneous and continuous degree of cellular XCI with extremes represented by “inactive” cells, i.e., exclusively expressing the escaping genes from the active X chromosome, and “escaping” cells, expressing the escapees from both alleles. Intriguingly we found that XIST is the major genetic determinant of IS, and that XIST expression, higher in G0 phase, is negatively correlated with the expression of escapees, inactivated and pseudoautosomal genes. In this study we use single-cell allele specific expression to identify novel escapees in different tissues and provide evidence of an unexpected cellular heterogeneity of XCI driven by a possible regulatory activity of XIST .