Comparison between acetonitrile-water separation by betaine and betaine hydrochloride

Acetonitrile and water are miscible solvents. This study compares their separation by betaine and betaine hydrochloride. Acetonitrile is a hydrogen (H) bond acceptor and so is betaine, because of its -CO and -CO- groups. Therefore, betaine competes with acetonitrile for interactions with the hydrogens of water molecules, as indicated by attenuated total reflectance - Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR). Therefore, when added to acetonitrile-water mixtures, betaine displaces acetonitrile. Separation into bulk phases occurs with 5–10 wt% betaine (relative to water), for acetonitrile concentrations between 50 and 80 wt% (relative to the aqueous phase). At lower acetonitrile concentrations (e.g., 1 wt%), betaine separates acetonitrile from water to yield emulsified acetonitrile droplets, detected by light scattering. With 1 wt% acetonitrile and betaine, acetonitrile droplets in water are negatively charged due to the -CO- group of betaine, as shown by electrophoretic measurements. In the case of betaine hydrochloride, the negative charge of the -CO- group is shielded by a proton, and interactions with water are weaker. As a result, bulk separation is not observed. Nonetheless, betaine hydrochloride also competes against acetonitrile for interactions with hydrogen atoms of water molecules, albeit not as effectively as betaine. This is shown by ATR-FTIR. Therefore, betaine hydrochloride emulsifies acetonitrile in water into sub-micron droplets. These droplets are positively charged, owing to the positively charged nitrogen atom of betaine hydrochloride. Acidifying mixtures of betaine, acetonitrile and water (with HCl) impedes bulk separation. This result confirms the importance of electrostatic interactions between the hydrogens of water and the unshielded, negative -CO- group of betaine.