Background: Most previous studies have evaluated flexion strength to assess recovery after arthroscopic rotator cuff (RC) repair. However, limited data are available regarding peak torque at the initial angle (iPT) because most studies have measured flexion strength for peak torque (PT), particularly in small- and medium-sized supraspinatus tears. The purpose of this study was to compare conventional PT and iPT to evaluate supraspinatus muscle strength after arthroscopic RC repair in patients with small- and medium-sized supraspinatus tears. Methods: Isokinetic muscle performance testing was performed in 42 patients with small tears and in 47 patients with medium-sized tears. PT and iPT were evaluated before and 1 year after surgery and were recorded at an angular velocity of 60°/sec and 180°/sec with an isokinetic test. Results: > 0.05). Conclusions: iPT is as important as conventional PT in isokinetic testing to assess supraspinatus muscle strength before and after RC repair.