摘要
Abstract Porphyry Cu (-Mo,Au) deposits constitute an ideal subject in the search for differences between “giant” and modest mineralization: these major magmatic-hydrothermal systems have been extensively, if somewhat erratically, analysed and documented, and embrace both a great range of size, from small (< 100,000 t Cu) to gigantic (> 45,000,000 t), and a corresponding diversity of paragenesis and fabric. Moreover, the lithotectonic and metallogenic contexts of several major porphyry provinces have been clarified. “Anatomical” variations among deposits are herein calibrated graphically against the intensively-studied El Salvador center, emphasizing those aspects of the temporal evolution of the mineralization most likely to reflect significant variations in magma-aqueous fluid equilibria, and hence fundamental ore-genetic parameters. It is regretfully concluded that, at least on the basis of the criteria selected, there are no systematic qualitative differences between outsize and smaller examples of the porphyry clan. Thus, significant departures from the El Salvador template are represented in all tonnage categories, and there is no correlation, between mineralization “complexity” and size. Whereas the two largest-known examples, Chuquicamata and El Teniente, display unusual features, they differ greatly from each other, and their specific attributes are not unique, and would probably not aid in the identification of other outsize deposits. The intensity of ore formation in porphyry deposits overall bears no simple or universal relationship to the P-T conditions prevailing in the broad environment in which retrograde boiling of granitoid magmas occurs. The underlying controls on deposit size must therefore reside mainly in larger-scale lithotectonic conditions; i.e., metallogenic parameters override the ore-genetic. However, it remains difficult to define the former. Whereas the ensialic central Andean orogen of Chile and southeastern Peru has been remarkably fecund as a porphyry copper nursery since the Paleogene, each of the world-class porphyry-dominated metallogenic episodes represented therein, viz., early Eocene, late Eocene-early Oligocene, and Late Miocene-Pliocene, occupies a significantly different geotectonic niche with respect both to plate convergence mode and tectonic/magmatic conditions at the continental margin. It is tentatively suggested that the giant, super-giant and behemothian porphyry deposits of this region may ultimately owe their origin to an unusually protracted (+200 m.y.) and fundamentally consistent magmatic history in the course of which only limited migration (≤ 150 km) of the main subduction-related arc occurred. Thus, parental melts generated in a poorly-defined but persistent and geochemically homogeneous (but increasingly Cu-rich?) zone in the lowermost crust or lithospheric upper mantle could periodically rise rapidly to the epizonal environment through a cordon sanitaire of essentially cogenetic precursor rocks. This minimized assimilation and fractional crystallization processes and hence precluded loss of Cu and Mo to the progressively-thickening crust. It is not clear to what extent such arguments may be germane to other less important porphyry provinces, but provenance and process considerations would be reconciled if the magmas associated with large-scale, central Andean, porphyry mineralization were significantly enriched in Cu, Mo, Cl and, possibly, S as a result of their unusual setting.