形成性评价
计算机科学
认知
科学教育
适应(眼睛)
光学(聚焦)
冗余(工程)
领域(数学分析)
选择(遗传算法)
教学设计
数学教育
工程教育
下一代科学标准
框架(结构)
认知负荷
移动设备
软件
教育技术
人工智能
数据科学
计算模型
自我效能感
终结性评价
心理学
知识管理
认知心理学
人机交互
任务分析
教学方法
多模态
逻辑推理
协议分析
重大挑战
作者
Kexin Jiang,Xiaoqin Xiao
标识
DOI:10.1080/10494820.2026.2679730
摘要
Integrating Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) into K–12 science education is promising, yet existing evaluations mainly focus on answer accuracy and overlook explanation quality, cognitive appropriateness, and response efficiency. This study systematically evaluates ten state-of-the-art MLLMs to examine whether they can answer correctly, explain pedagogically, and operate efficiently in K–12 science contexts. Using the ScienceQA benchmark, we conduct a zero-shot chain-of-thought evaluation across three dimensions: accuracy, Pedagogical Explanation Score, and reasoning latency, with results interpreted through cognitive load theory. The findings reveal a “visual redundancy paradox”: adding images can degrade performance by increasing extraneous cognitive load. Although most models generate fluent explanations, they still lack adaptive scaffolding for learners. Fine-tuning experiments further show that the locally deployed Qwen2-VL model achieves substantial accuracy gains while maintaining low latency, indicating the value of lightweight domain adaptation for real-time educational applications. Based on these results, we propose a latency-aware model selection strategy: locally deployed Qwen2-VL and low-latency API services are suitable for high-frequency formative assessment, while higher-performing flagship models are better reserved for deep inquiry or batch-style instructional support.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI