Evaluating Selective Quality Control in Mammalian Oogenesis: Evidence and Opportunities

The formation and maintenance of the finite mammalian ovarian reserve are critical for fertility and species survival. Genetic and developmental studies have uncovered various mechanisms underlying oocyte development and maturation, revealing two curious features of the ovarian germline: (a) The establishment of the follicle reserve involves an initial massive overproduction of oocyte precursors, and (b) the total number of ovulated oocytes across an animal's fertile lifetime is a very small proportion of the initial ovarian reserve. Many have proposed that this indicates the existence of selective quality control to ensure gamete fitness. Here, we review the findings underlying the hypotheses for germline quality control during prepubertal development, homeostatic fertility, and reproductive aging. We evaluate whether the existing evidence base distinguishes the active selection of specific germ cell subsets from neutral dynamics. Throughout, we discuss strategies for applying statistical frameworks to evaluate selection in oogenesis and the implications of neutrality versus selection at various points in oocyte development.