生物标志物
匹配(统计)
统计
人口
排名(信息检索)
计算机科学
二元分析
计量经济学
医学
人工智能
数学
生物
环境卫生
生物化学
作者
MARGARET SULLIVAN PEPE,Jing Fan,Christopher W. Seymour,Christopher Li,Ying Huang,Ziding Feng
出处
期刊:Clinical Chemistry
[American Association for Clinical Chemistry]
日期:2012-06-23
卷期号:58 (8): 1242-1251
被引量:50
标识
DOI:10.1373/clinchem.2012.186007
摘要
BACKGROUND: Selecting controls that match cases on risk factors for the outcome is a pervasive practice in biomarker research studies. Such matching, however, biases estimates of biomarker prediction performance. The magnitudes of these biases are unknown. METHODS: We examined the prediction performance of biomarkers and improvements in prediction gained by adding biomarkers to risk factor information. Data simulated from bivariate normal statistical models and data from a study to identify critically ill patients were used. We compared true performance with that estimated from case control studies that do or do not use matching. ROC curves were used to quantify performance. We propose a new statistical method to estimate prediction performance from matched studies for which data on the matching factors are available for subjects in the population. RESULTS: Performance estimated with standard analyses can be grossly biased by matching, especially when biomarkers are highly correlated with matching risk factors. In our studies, the performance of the biomarker alone was underestimated whereas the improvement in performance gained by adding the marker to risk factors was overestimated by 2-10-fold. We found examples for which the relative ranking of 2 biomarkers for prediction was inappropriately reversed by use of a matched design. The new approach to estimation corrected for bias in matched studies. CONCLUSIONS: To properly gauge prediction performance in the population or the improvement gained by adding a biomarker to known risk factors, matched case control studies must be supplemented with risk factor information from the population and must be analyzed with nonstandard statistical methods.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI