The effects of different types of learning engagement on learning outcomes: An ICAP follow-up study
作者
Christina Wekerle,Michael Sailer,Tim Fütterer
出处
期刊: [Center for Open Science] 日期:2024-07-26
标识
DOI:10.17605/osf.io/kju36
摘要
Background: The Interactive-Constructive-Active-Passive (ICAP) framework makes assumptions about the relationships between observable types of learning activities (passive, active, constructive, interactive), cognitive processes, and learning outcomes. Yet, methodological issues and empirical results of ICAP-based studies cast doubts on the validity of the ICAP framework. Aims: This study investigates the effects of student engagement in passive, active, constructive and interactive learning activities on their surface and deep knowledge gain, as well as their motivation. Additionally, the study aims to determine the associations between students’ cognitive processes and their learning activities, surface and deep knowledge gain. Sample: Participants were 247 pre-service teachers. Methods: After reading a text on multimedia learning, participants were asked to reread the text (passive condition), to underline central information in the text (active condition), to work on three open-ended tasks addressing the text (constructive condition), or to work on the same tasks in pairs (interactive condition). Results: No statistically significant effects of condition on surface or deep knowledge could be detected. Regarding motivation, participants in the interactive condition reported statistically significantly higher levels of perceived relatedness compared to all other conditions. Furthermore, only participants in the interactive condition reported statistically significantly higher levels of interactive cognitive processes compared to those in all other conditions. Constructive cognitive processes were statistically significantly negatively associated with deep knowledge gain. All other associations were not statistically significant. Conclusion: The findings suggest that the empirical foundation supporting the ICAP framework may not yet be sufficiently robust. Yet, more research is needed that applies a more rigorous methodology exploring the ICAP framework.