作者
Yafei Chen,Dajie Zhang,Yu Zhu,Baoli Song,Hui Wang,Wenjia Yang,Lina Yin,Shiwen Wang
摘要
Sustainable intensification of crop production requires reconciling the fundamental trade-off between enhancing soil organic carbon (SOC) sequestration and promoting its decomposition for crop nutrient supply. Conservation practices like no-tillage (NT) and straw return (SR) are widely promoted. However, a quantitative understanding of their synergistic or trade-off effects on SOC stocks and crop yield at regional scales, along with the underlying driving mechanisms, remains lacking. Using an integrated meta-analysis and machine learning approach, we analyzed 1425 observations from 107 studies to quantify the effects of NT, SR, and their combination (NTSR) on SOC stocks and crop yield, predict the spatial probability of synergy, and elucidate underlying mechanisms in the drylands of Northwest China. The results revealed that NT exacerbated the trade-off between SOC stock (+8.33%, P < 0.05 ) and crop yield (–5.07%, P < 0.05 ). SR demonstrated a significant synergistic effect (SOC stock: +8.65%; Yield: +7.90%, P < 0.05 ), but its yield-enhancing effect was influenced by the baseline SOC stock, reaching a plateau (+2.22%) as SOC stock increased. Notably, NTSR reconciled the trade-off observed under NT, showing the strongest synergy (SOC stock: +12.19%; Yield: +12.41%, P < 0.05 ). The effectiveness of these practices was significantly influenced by climate and soil properties, exhibiting strong regional heterogeneity. Spatially, the synergy probability for NT was less than 50% across the drylands of Northwest China. SR showed a higher synergy probability in the semi-arid and semi-humid croplands of Northwest China (e.g., Shanxi, Shaanxi, and central Inner Mongolia). Notably, NTSR significantly expanded the synergy probability of NT alone, particularly in the hyper‑arid inland basin of western Xinjiang, the semi‑arid zone of southern Gansu and northern Ningxia, and the semi‑humid zone of southern Shanxi. Further analysis indicated that SOC-yield synergy of NTSR was closely associated with its enhancement of the interactions and availability of soil total phosphorus, total nitrogen, available phosphorus, and available potassium. These findings identify potential thresholds for practice suitability and suggest that NTSR may represent a promising strategy for sustainable intensification, mitigating SOC limitations to co-enhance productivity and carbon sequestration in the drylands of Northwest China, which are characterized by low SOC, alkaline soils, and highly variable precipitation. Beyond regional applications, our analysis provides a scalable framework to evaluate conservation agriculture for reconciling food security and climate resilience goals in analogous drylands worldwide.