摘要
This editorial refers to ‘Right heart strain in arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy: Implications for cardiovascular outcome’, by S. Anwer et al., https://doi.org/10.1093/ehjci/jeae117. In the last decade, there has been increasing interest in right-sided heart diseases, such as arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy (ARVC), both in understanding the pathophysiology of the diseases and in the clinical relevance of right heart imaging parameters. ARVC is one of the few cardiomyopathies that predominantly affect the right heart, often beginning in the right ventricular (RV) free wall, with a progressive loss of myocytes replaced by fibrofatty tissue, leading to predominant ventricular arrhythmias in the early stage of the disease and RV failure in advanced stage.1 Therefore, early detection and risk assessment are important to prevent sudden cardiac death. Echocardiographic RV longitudinal strain has been shown to be a promising parameter at an early stage of the disease. Normal segmental RV strain patterns were associated with an absence of disease progression during a 4-year follow-up in patients with ARVC,2 while both abnormal RV strain patterns and prolonged RV mechanical dispersion have been shown to be associated with ventricular arrhythmic events.3,4 A recent expert consensus document therefore proposed using RV longitudinal strain, both RV global strain (RVGLS) and RV free wall strain, and RV mechanical dispersion in follow-up of ARVC.5 In the current issue of European Heart Journal—Cardiovascular Imaging, Anwer et al.6 assessed the prognostic utility of the right heart strain in patients with diagnosis of definite ARVC from the Swiss ARVC Registry. The authors evaluated the prognostic impact of RVGLS and right atrial (RA) reservoir strain (RAGLS) and compared them to other conventional risk factors. At a median follow-up of nearly 5 years, the combined primary endpoint, defined as sustained ventricular arrhythmia and cardiovascular death, was achieved in approximately one-third of the entire study cohort, which confirms that patients with ARVC are at substantial risk of adverse clinical outcome.7 Consistent with previous studies,4,8 patients with ARVC with the cardiovascular events had more pronounced remodelling of the right heart and impaired RV function, as assessed by both RVGLS and RV free wall strain. Besides RVGLS, also RAGLS was associated with adverse cardiovascular events independently of age, gender, and conventional RV parameters. Importantly, when RVGLS an RAGLS were applied together in a prediction model, the predictive value of the model significantly improved. Previous studies that characterized the determinants of the left heart strain have shown that the left ventricle (LV) and left atrium (LA) are mechanically connected and share the motion of the mitral ring, resulting in a strong interdependence of atrial and ventricular strain. Therefore, left atrial strain is to a large extent determined by LV strain and further modulated by the volume ratio of LV and LA.9 The same is also expected for the right heart strain. The effect of the adjacent chambers, the RV and also the LA, on the deformation of the RA could be even more pronounced, as these adjacent chambers have higher pressures than the RA through the cardiac cycle.10 Although RVGLS and RAGLS might be partially concordant, both parameters were independently associated with cardiovascular events in patients with ARVC in the current study.6 Additionally, the combination of these two deformation parameters outperformed the individual parameters in predicting cardiovascular adverse events. This suggests that both RVGLS and RAGLS are complementary and may reflect different proarrhythmogenic and prognostic properties of the myocardium. Therefore, RA strain in patients with ARVC might not only integrate information on RV function, chamber dimensions, and haemodynamics, but also reflects intrinsic atrial function. This is further supported by histopathological findings showing pathological changes of fibrofatty replacement and fibrosis also in the RA myocardium in ARVC models, leading to atrial dysfunction.11 The study by Anwer et al.6 has several limitations. The authors analysed only RVGLS and RV free wall strain, whereas previous studies have shown that regional heterogeneity in RV contraction, assessed by prolonged mechanical dispersion or abnormal segmental strain patterns, is a strong predictor of arrhythmic events and it seems to work even better than RV strain.3,4 Direct comparison of the combination of RVGLS and RAGLS with mechanical dispersion or external validation of the right heart strain in a second validation cohort would strengthen the validation for routine clinical use. In the current study, RA strain was associated with outcome independently of age and gender, with RAGLS ≤ 28.3% as the best cut-off value for differentiating patients at higher risk of an event.6 Previous data have reported a wide range of RA strain values in normal subjects and their association with anthropometric and clinical variables.12,13 Further data are needed to better define pathological changes in the RA strain in disease states. Additionally, it is unknown how many cases were excluded due to poor image quality or how many segments of the RV were excluded due to suboptimal tracking. RA images are often of poorer quality, and the feasibility for the strain is the lowest for the RA strain compared to the other chambers.13 RA strain was performed by non-dedicated tracking software. A recent study investigating LA strain showed that dedicated tracking software significantly improved reproducibility for strain measurement.14 However, in the current study by Anwer et al.,6 the reproducibility analysis showed excellent reliability with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.90. It is questionable whether such reproducibility of RAGLS could be achieved in clinical practice. We congratulate the authors on this comprehensive analysis of the right heart strain in patients with ARVC. This study provides a new insight into understanding the pathogenesis of the ARVC, potentially making RAGLS an important marker of disease severity and also a predictor of prognosis. Additionally, the results of the study suggest that RAGLS has an important incremental prognostic value on top of the well-known RV strain. We could now potentially consider the inclusion of RA strain in the echocardiographic assessment of patients with ARVC. However, further validation studies are needed, and we look forward to new studies testing the clinical model with parameters of right heart strain to better stratify this high-risk population. No new data were generated or analysed in support of this research.