The objective of this paper is to advocate the use of Bayesian methods in tackling decision problems with limited past data. It is assumed that a Bayesian approach is least likely to be successful when there is no information on which to base a meaningful prior. Here we use a limiting, invariant, form of the conjugate prior distribution to represent this ignorance. The results of decisions based on Bayesian methods with this ‘non-informative’ prior are compared with those which result from deriving a point estimate for the unknown parameter. The particular context considered here is that of a single-period inventory model with compound Poisson demand made up of a known demand size distribution but an unknown demand rate. The demand rate is assumed to be high enough for a normal approximation to the compound Poisson distribution to be used, in which case it is possible to analyse the behaviour directly. An extension to the multi-period model with zero lead time is considered briefly. The results lend support to the use of Bayesian methods, with or without a meaningful prior, for which the analysis and computation are no more complex than those required by standard methods.