分类
路径(计算)
认识论
解释水平理论
计算机科学
可信赖性
本质主义
循环(图论)
数理经济学
实证经济学
工作(物理)
经济
机制(生物学)
路径依赖
标识
DOI:10.1080/09515089.2026.2718428
摘要
This paper seeks an account of what types of reactions to being classified can trigger a demand to revise the original classifications and therefore instigate a feedback loop According to one view, such looping effects happen if and only if classifying a kind changes which properties are correlated with kind membership (correlationism). According to another, they happen if and only if classifying a kind changes its essential properties (essentialism). I argue that correlationism implied looping effects where there are none and that essentialism either collapses back into correlationism (on a broad construal of “essential property”) or implies that looping effects are impossible. In response, I develop and defend a view according to which a looping effect happens if and only if the effects of classifying a kind depend, in part, on the existing nature of that kind (explanationism). I show that explanationism forges a path between the above extremes and that it offers new insights about old examples of looping effects, not least about the sort of evidence we should need to justify the claim that a looping effect has occurred or that a kind is susceptible to looping effects.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI