Although response to a stressor is a continuous and dynamic process, most organizational research treats it as a static event. This experimental study addresses largely overlooked temporal aspects of the work stressor-performance relationship with a focus on task difficulty and challenge and hindrance appraisals. Specifically, we examine how task performance, provided as organizational performance feedback (i.e., the simultaneous display of objective feedback and upward social comparison feedback) is related to changes in challenge and hindrance appraisals in a low and high difficulty cognitive task. Task difficulty was manipulated in the n-back task. In a sample of 267 participants, we find that task performance, provided as organizational performance feedback, mediates change in challenge and hindrance appraisals. This finding supports the proposition that individual responses to a stressor are dynamic and change during a demanding encounter and that task performance, provided as organizational performance feedback can explain these changes.