Costs and benefits linked to developments in cognitive control

Abstract Developing cognitive control over one's thoughts, emotions, and actions is a fundamental process that predicts important life outcomes. Such control begins in infancy, and shifts during development from a predominantly reactive form (e.g. retrieving task‐relevant information when needed) to an increasingly proactive form (e.g. maintaining task‐relevant information in anticipation of needing it). While such developments are generally viewed as adaptive, cognitive abilities can also involve trade‐offs, such that the benefits of developing increasingly proactive control may come with associated costs. In two experiments, we test for such cognitive trade‐offs in children who are transitioning to proactive control. We find that proactive control predicts expected benefits in children's working memory, but is also associated with predicted costs in disproportionately slowing children under conditions of distraction. These findings highlight unique advantages and disadvantages of proactive and reactive control, and suggest caution in attempting to alter their balance during development.