Why do some firms become primarily suppliers of trade credit and other firms become primarily buyers of trade credit? A theoretical model is proposed and suggests that the determining factors of the net trade credit position are size and liquidity. The model predicts a nonmonotonic net trade credit - firm performance nexus with a net trade credit threshold splitting firms to sufficiently "small and illiquid" that benefit more from receiving trade credit, even when operating at a negative net trade credit, and "large and more liquid" firms that benefit more from extending trade credit. The results of the model are confirmed empirically using a large sample of European SMEs, and the net trade credit threshold is estimated while dealing carefully with endogeneity and nonmonotonicity, simultaneously.