Extant research shows illegitimate tasks (i-tasks)— work assignments considered either unnecessary or unreasonable and, therefore, outside employees' legitimate work roles—are stressors causing worker strain. However, a growing number of research studies reveal potential positive outcomes of i-tasks. The present study furthers this line of research by investigating whether fulfilling unreasonable tasks leads to valuable resources known as idiosyncratic deals (i-deals) which are special privileges granted to select employees but not all other employees. A time-lagged survey of over 300 adult employees in the United States found that completing unreasonable tasks handed to them by their supervisors made employees feel their supervisors were indebted to them. This perceived indebtedness enhanced employees' negotiation self-efficacy, ultimately leading to them receiving more task i-deals from their leaders. Contingent reward leadership, a specific dimension of the transactional leadership approach, was found to moderate this relationship. Specifically, an indirect effect of unreasonable task completion on receiving task i-deals was observed only when contingent reward leadership was high. These findings suggest that while unreasonable tasks can be seen as burdensome, they can also lead to valuable outcomes under certain conditions. Practical implications and future research directions are discussed, highlighting the nuanced impact of i-tasks in the workplace.