Comment on egusphere-2023-84

Abstract. Soil bioturbation activity affects soil texture, bulk density, soil water content and redistribution of nutrients. All of these parameters influences sediment redistribution, which shapes the earth surface. Hence it is important to include bioturbation into erosion models. However, up to present, the inclusion of bioturbation into erosion models was limited. This is because to realistically include bioturbation into the modelling, the interplay between bioturbation, sediment redistribution and environmental parameters is not understood. Here, we included bioturbation into a soil erosion model and interpreted the impacts of bioturbation on sediment redistribution. To do this, we measured the needed soil properties and location of burrows created by bioturbating animals in four research sites located along the Chilean climate gradient. Then, we parametrized a semi-empirical erosion model by applying machine learning algorithms to upscale soil properties and burrow distribution. We ran the model for a time period of 6 years under two conditions: With and without bioturbation. We validated the model using several sediment fences in the field. We estimated the modelled sediment redistribution and surface runoff in all climate zones. Lastly, we identified environmental parameters determining the positive or negative impact of bioturbation on sediment redistribution. We found that the model with integrated bioturbation performed much better (R² = 0.71, RMSE = 0.63) than the model without integrated bioturbation (R² = 0.17, RMSE = 1.18), meaning that model runs which considered bioturbation predicted the sediment redistribution more realistically. Furthermore, bioturbation increased sediment redistribution in all but the humid climate zone, especially in the Mediterranean zone. The quantity of sediment redistributed due to bioturbation was reliant on an interplay between elevation, slope, surface roughness and sink connectivity. Overall, bioturbation enhances sediment erosion in areas where more erosion is expected, and enhances sediment accumulation in areas which are more prone to accumulate sediment. In other words, considering bioturbation when studying earth surface evolution means an amplification of existing tendencies in sediment redistribution, and leads to a faster hillslope relief equalisation.