This study examines consumer responses to local and regional dairy brands in Tennessee including their progression through a 4-stage marketing funnel – brand awareness, purchase intent, repurchase likelihood, and recommendation likelihood – when considering 7 dairy brands (6 real, one hypothetical). Using an in-person survey, we find that brand awareness represents the binding constraint for local small creameries with brand awareness rates below 10%, whereas awareness is 93% for the established regional brand. Engagement with farm-direct retail channels and approval of local food buying promote local dairy brand awareness and initial purchase likelihood for those products. Conditional on purchase, perceived quality emerges as the dominant driver of both repurchase and recommendation intentions. The local brand exhibits significantly higher recommendation likelihood than purchasers of the regional brand, suggesting word of mouth advocacy among engaged consumers. Closing the awareness gap represents the major challenge for regional and local dairy brands.