Temperature is a fundamental parameter in reaction kinetics, typically accelerating rates according to the Arrhenius law. In catalytic systems, however, competing pathways often respond differently to temperature, allowing selective promotion of desired reactions while suppressing undesired ones through temperature modulation. Here, we show that regulating temperature near the freezing point of water can resolve the activity-stability trade-off in the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) on manganese dioxide. Although lowering the temperature decreased OER rates, the catalyst degradation through permanganate formation was suppressed more effectively, extending catalyst lifetime. Counterintuitively, further cooling below 0 °C accelerated permanganate formation, yielding an optimum temperature near 0 °C that balances activity and stability. This anti-Arrhenius behavior, arising from electrolyte supercooling, represents a rare example of anomalous temperature-dependent electrocatalysis under subzero conditions. Our findings highlight temperature regulation as a viable strategy for enhancing catalytic lifetime, with implications for electrochemical systems operating in wintertime, polar, and extraterrestrial environments.