Existing studies within the behavioral theory of the firm (BToF) tend to loosely adopt simplified cause and effect models, neglecting essential context-dependence stemming from moderators that may affect the direction and breadth of firm problemistic search behaviors. We develop and empirically test a comprehensive organizational search model, focusing on tightening the linkage of search activities with essential industry and firm characteristics. Our framework comprehensively adapts past research used to predict the direction of organizational problemistic search with respect to investments in R&D, operations, or acquisitions. We hypothesize, test, and support the impact of specific industry-level (capital intensity and dynamism) and firm-level (history of search activities) moderators on search activities. We contribute to the BToF literature by elucidating a granular linkage between stimulus (performance shortfall) and managerial decision making with respect to problemistic search, and firm behavior.