Origins of the osmoprotective properties of betaine and proline in Escherichia coli K-12

The amounts of cytoplasmic water and of all osmotically significant cytoplasmic solutes were determined for Escherichia coli K-12 grown in 3-(N-morpholino)propane sulfonate (MOPS)-buffered glucose-minimal medium containing 0.5 M NaCl in the presence and absence of the osmoprotectants betaine and proline. The goal of this work is to correlate the effects of osmoprotectants on the composition of the cytoplasm with their ability to increase the growth rate of osmotically stressed cells. At a concentration of 1 mM in the growth medium, betaine increases the growth rate more than does proline; choline, which is converted to betaine by E. coli, appears to have an intermediate effect on growth rate. The accumulation of either betaine or proline reduces the cytoplasmic amounts of K+, glutamate, trehalose, and MOPS (the major cytoplasmic osmolytes accumulated in the absence of osmoprotectants), so that at this external osmolarity the total amount of cytoplasmic solutes is essentially the same in the presence or absence of either osmoprotectant. More betaine than proline is accumulated, so the extent of replacement of cytoplasmic solutes is greater for betaine than for proline. Accumulation of these osmoprotectants is accompanied by a large (20 to 50%) increase in the volume of cytoplasmic water per unit of cell dry weight (Vcyto). This effect, which appears to result from an increase in the volume of free water, Vf (as opposed to water of hydration, or bound water), is greater for betaine than for proline. Taken together, these results indicate that the molar effects of betaine and proline on water activity and on the osmotic pressure of the cytoplasm must be significantly larger than those of the solutes they replace. Cayley et al. (S. Cayley, B. A. Lewis, H. J. Guttman, and M. T. Record, Jr., J. Mol. Biol. 222:281-300, 1991) observed that, in cells grown in the absence of osmoprotectants, both growth rate and Vcyto decreased, whereas the amount of cytoplasmic K+ (nK+) increased, with increasing external osmolarity. We predicted that the observed changes in nK+ and Vcyto would have large and approximately compensating effects on key protein-nucleic acid interactions of gene expression, and we proposed that Vf was the fundamental determinant of growth rate in osmotically stressed cells. The properties of cells cultured in the presence of betaine and proline appear completely consistent with our previous work and proposals. Accumulation of betaine and, to a lesser extent, proline shifts the set of linked physiological parameters (nK+, Vcyto, growth rate) to those characteristic of growth at lower osmolarity in the absence of osmoprotectants. Models for the thermodynamic basis and physiological consequences of the effect of osmoprotectants on Vcyto and Vf are discussed.