A comparison of dietary selection behaviour in larval Locusta migratoria and Spodoptera littoralis

ABSTRACT. . Final instar nymphs of the oligophagous acridid Locusta migratoria (L.) and larvae of the polyphagous noctuid Spodoptera littoralis (Boisduval) were fed for 4, 8 or 12 h, the conditioning period, on one of four artificial diets. Of these, diet PC contained 20% protein and 10% digestible carbohydrate; another, P, contained 20% protein but with the digestible carbohydrate component replaced by cellulose; a third, C, had the protein component substituted by cellulose, and the fourth, O, had both protein and digestible carbohydrate replaced. After this conditioning period, insects were given a choice of two diets, P and C, and hence an opportunity to select for the nutrients, if any, which were lacking in their previous food. Amounts eaten and selection behaviour were then recorded in detail for a total of 9 h. This paper deals with total amounts of diet eaten during the conditioning and choice periods. Spodoptera larvae were more sensitive than the locusts to being fed a nutritionally inadequate conditioning diet, and ate only small quantities of the P, C and O diets as compared with the PC diet, irrespective of the duration of conditioning. Locusts, on the other hand, when restricted to the P diet continued to eat relatively large amounts of it throughout a 12 h conditioning period. Those nymphs fed the C diet ingested large quantities (more than of the PC diet) up until 8 h, after which intake fell. When offered a choice, both species selected for the nutrients missing from the conditioning diet, even if the conditioning period had been as short as 4 h. During the first hour of choice locusts selected the P diet if they had been previously fed C and the C diet if previously fed P. Those deprived of both nutrients increased consumption of both P and C diets. Spodoptera larvae were more sensitive to prior deprivation of digestible carbohydrate than of protein. During the first hour of choice they selected the C diet if previously fed P or O but did not choose the P diet if previously fed C. In the subsequent 8 h of choice, however, a strong selection for the P diet after previous deprivation became apparent. In the locust, the selection for nutrients missing from the conditioning diet continued for the following 8 h of choice but became masked by a tendency, shown by all nymphs, to select C over P. The functional significance and possible physiological basis of all these responses is discussed.