摘要
Experiences of threat may motivate people to adopt a collective spirit, seeking empowerment and agency through group membership and collective action – potentially aimed at challenging a detrimental status quo. However, such threat experiences may also foster a form of false consciousness, characterized by ideological beliefs or conservative attitudes that legitimize and preserve the status quo – even when it is the very source of people’s plight. This dissertation addresses this paradox by investigating the psychological processes through which individuals respond to experiences of personal control threat. Drawing on and extending two prominent theoretical frameworks – Compensatory Control Theory (CCT) and Group Based Control Theory (GBCT) – this dissertation explores how individuals seek to regain a sense of agency at the collective level of their identity to buffer personal control loss, and under which conditions they instead resort to uncertainty-reduction strategies, such as seeking structure and order in the environment, to cope with the adverse consequences of control threat. In doing so, it develops and provides initial empirical support for the Integrated Stage Model of Extended and Secondary Control (INSMESC). According to INSMESC, individuals first attempt to restore control through personal or collective agency. Only when these agency-restorative routes are perceived as unavailable or ineffective do individuals turn to secondary strategies aimed at reducing uncertainty by seeking and affirming existing (social) structures and sources of order. Across four papers – three empirical and one theoretical – this dissertation explores how personal control threats shape cognition, attitudes, and behavioral intentions in socio-political contexts. The first paper (7 Studies; total N = 2787) introduces the concept of illusory collective control, showing that under control threat, individuals exaggerate the perceived agency of salient ingroups and their leaders – but only when they strongly identify with them. This demonstrates that experiencing collective agency is a pivotal desire for people whose personal control has been diminished. The second paper (5 Studies; total N = 2063) then examines whether people’s increased support for social hierarchies under control threat, previously explained as a desire for structure (CCT), may instead serve to boost the ingroup’s collective agency (GBCT) as a buffer for personal control loss. Across five studies, control threat consistently increased support for social hierarchies – but only when these hierarchies were framed or perceived as enhancing the ingroup’s agency, and when identification with the group was high. This pattern underscores the primacy of agency-restorative over uncertainty-reduction motives in contexts of personal control threat: if uncertainty-reduction were the primary motive, even unagentic or outgroup hierarchies should have elicited similar support. The third paper (5 studies; total N = 2045) examines how personal control threat shapes individuals’ responses to social change, depending on whether this change is initiated by an ingroup or an outgroup. The findings reveal that control threat increases support for ingroup-led change – but not for the maintenance of the status quo – while reducing support when change is initiated by an outgroup. These results suggest that, under threat, individuals prefer ingroup-led change over stability, as it provides a powerful signal of collective agency. In contrast, they reject outgroup-led change, as it disrupts existing structures and thus threatens epistemic certainty. This pattern supports the core proposition of INSMESC: that individuals primarily seek to restore control through collective agency. Only when this pathway is perceived as unavailable do they shift to uncertainty-reducing strategies, which in turn lead to resistance to social change. Finally, in the fourth paper the full conceptualization of INSMESC is presented. It clarifies the motivational structure underlying responses to control threat by distinguishing between agency-restorative and uncertainty-reduction motives. By and large, this dissertation integrates and systematizes previous research on CCT and GBCT and offers a novel theoretical framework for understanding the emergence of qualitatively different strategies to restore personal control.:1 Introduction 1 1.1 Collective Spirit or False Consciousness? 1 1.2 Threat as a source of motivated thoughts and action 2 2 Theoretical Part 6 2.1 Control as a Basic Human Need and Responses to Control Threats 6 2.2 Compensatory Control Theory: Control Threat and the Pursuit of Structure and Order 7 2.3 Group-Based Control Theory: Collective Agency under Conditions of Threat 9 2.4 The Integrated Stage Model of Extended and Secondary Control 12 3 Empirical Part (Interim Summaries) 15 3.1 Paper 1: Illusory Collective Control – Group-Based Control as Motivated Cognition 15 3.2 Paper 2: Agency Through Hierarchy – A Group-Based Control Perspective on Compensatory Control Phenomena 17 3.3 Paper 3: Change, Yes “We” Can – Collective Action and Social Change under Control Threat 20 3.4 Paper 4: Let’s Take Back Control – Introducing the Integrated Stage Model of Extended and Secondary Control 22 4 Overarching Discussion 23 4.1 Limitations and Future Directions 28 4.2 General Conclusion 31 5 References List (Introductory Part) 33 6 Research Articles 41 6.1 Illusory collective control: Motivated collective agency perceptions as a response to threatened personal control in highly and lowly identified group members (under review) 41 6.2 Agency through hierarchy? A group-based account of increased approval of social hierarchies under conditions of threatened control (published at Journal of Experimental Social Psychology) 95 6.3 Change, yes ‘we’ can: Protesting for (ingroup) and against (outgroup) change under conditions of threatened personal control (published at Journal of Experimental Social Psychology) 115 6.4 Let’s take back control: Disentangling and integrating group-based and certainty-based social responses to threatened personal control (published at European Review of Social Psychology) 135 7 Summary 185 8 Zusammenfassung 191 9 Reference List Summary / Zusammenfassung 197 10 Appendix A. Curriculum Vitae 201 11 Appendix B. List of publications 202 12 Appendix C. Nachweis über Anteile der Co-Autor:innen 204