Using 2014-2024 data from Chinese A-share listed companies, this research examines how inconsistent ESG ratings affect corporate supply chain resilience. Greater rating disagreement is linked to a notable drop in resilience. Industry competition amplifies this effect: higher concentration makes the negative impact stronger. The eastern region shows the strongest effect, while pollution level does not matter—heavily and lightly polluting firms are similarly affected. The results give fresh insight into ESG rating inconsistency and offer practical direction for regulators pursuing uniform ESG criteria, as well as for firms striving to boost supply chain resilience.