This study uses polynomial regression with response surface analysis to examine the congruence effect of authoritarianism and benevolence from paternalistic leadership theories. This integrative method can fix the misalignment between theoretical arguments and empirical tests of paternalistic leadership, such that previous studies usually treat authoritarianism and benevolence as separate dimensions of paternalistic leadership. Using data from 566 high-school basketball athletes from 42 teams in Taiwan, we empirically show that congruent paternalistic leadership (i.e., high authoritarianism and high benevolence) has a positive effect on follower satisfaction. Moreover, this positive effect is further reinforced when follower-rated cohesion or affective trust is high, highlighting the role of contextual factors in paternalistic leadership. The theoretical and practical implications of these findings are discussed.