Directors’ positive duty to act in the interests of the entity: shareholders’ interests bounded by corporate purpose

Directors’ duty to act in good faith and to act in the best interests of the company relates to the interests of shareholders held in the company as a separate legal entity. The obligation to act in the best interests of shareholders is potentially bounded by corporate purpose as the office requires directors to act in accordance with the constitution and Companies Act. The origin of the duty is traced to the emergence of permanent capital in the business corporation and the resulting new oaths sworn by directors in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries with Charitable Corporation v Sutton considered in that historical context. The analysis illustrates that the duty is not owed to shareholders collectively at any time, but rather to the company as a separate entity from its shareholders. The interests of shareholders are held in the company as its capital base. The duty is considered in relation to the even longer-standing obligation that officers of corporations act faithfully to ensure compliance with the corporation’s charter. The article concludes that the re-inclusion of purpose provisions in company constitutions combined with recognition that the modern company is an entity rather than contractual could significantly influence the application of the good faith and best interests duty.