The study estimated the shelf life of specialty coffee packaged in six types of packaging (Tocuyo bag (TB), Double-bilaminate foil and aluminuim bag (DFAB), Ecotac vacuum bag (EV), Pressed cardboard box (PCB), Double-laminated bag without valve, with opening and zipper (DBOZ), Double-laminated bag with degassing valve and zipper (DBDVZ) and Triple-laminated bag with degassing valve and zipper (TBDVZ)). The estimation of shelf life was conducted by means of cup scores provided by six coffee tasters for coffee stored at 40, 50, and 60 °C. The Arrhenius equation was employed to obtain accelerated models for predicting shelf life. It was determined that green coffee beans are most effectively preserved in DBOZ, maintaining their freshness for a period of up to 55.13 days. The second-best option was EV, which has a shelf life of up to 35.21 days. The sole packaging alternative that was subjected to testing for roasted coffee beans was found to allow for their preservation for a period of up to 32 days. However, for roasted and ground coffee, of the four alternatives evaluated, the TBDVZ proved to be the optimal alternative, at 12.18 days. However, the other alternatives (DBOZ and DBDVZ) allow for very similar storage times, at 11.99 and 11.48 days, respectively. PCB does not appear to be a viable packaging alternative for roasted and ground coffee (7.85 days). Finally, we found that coffee stored in DFAB and aluminum bags at 20 °C has been shown to retain its quality for up to 250 days. Furthermore, if the temperature is reduced to 10 °C, the coffee’s shelf life is extended to more than 600 days. The insights derived from this research are of significant value to industry stakeholders, consumers, and developers of specialty coffee packaging.