Arrogant communications in advertising presents a double-edged sword for brands, potentially yielding improved effectiveness when used appropriately and risking negative impressions from consumers when used inappropriately. The focus of this research is on visual arrogance in advertising. Specifically, this research investigates the effect of arrogant expressions, compared with smiling and neutral expressions, on two consumer responses, namely attention and purchase. The findings of three studies provide consistent evidence that arrogant expressions would enhance consumer attention, including attention time and brand recall. Arrogant expressions would increase purchase intention when aligned with a brand’s position, but have a negative effect when misaligned.