形成性评价
数学教育
心理学
探索性研究
阅读(过程)
教育学
定性研究
教学方法
计算机科学
泛读
行动研究
学习评价
多元方法论
数据收集
评价方法
半结构化面试
医学教育
干预(咨询)
自我效能感
探索性因素分析
阅读理解
学业成绩
作者
Ziqi Chen,Wei Wei,Yiqian Cao,Jessica To
标识
DOI:10.1080/17501229.2025.2553208
摘要
Purpose While evaluation-based feedback has been widely advocated in language assessment research for its perceived utility, this study examined and compared the effectiveness of three types of GenAI formative feedback within secondary education reading assessments.Design/methodology/approach This study employed an exploratory sequential mixed methods design, guided by the Student-Feedback Interaction Model. Six teachers evaluated GenAI formative feedback provided to 516 Year 9 students on constructed-response reading tasks. Feedback types included: (1) answer revisions, (2) reading strategy recommendations, and (3) additional task recommendations. Qualitative data were collected from post-evaluation interviews.Findings Contrary to prevailing feedback research that positions recommendation as more impactful than revision, MANCOVA tests reveal GenAI revision feedback was rated significantly more effectively than recommendation feedback across classical, fiction, and technical writing reading genres. Qualitative data from post-evaluation interviews revealed key limitations of GenAI’s recommendation on reading strategies and tasks: (1) repetition and copied materials; (2) limited development of knowledge transfer; (3) irrelevance to high-stakes exams; (4) generic and non-contextualized recommendations; and (5) overly complex language for lower proficiency students.Originality/value This study provides the first empirical evidence demonstrating that GenAI formative feedback proves more effective for answer revision than strategy recommendation. It advances genre-specific insights by revealing GenAI’s greater efficacy in classical literature tasks compared to fiction or technical texts. Practically, the research proposes a feedback-literate GenAI integration model that addresses five limitations of recommendation-based approaches (including repetitiveness, transferability gaps, and exam misalignment), offering educators actionable principles to implement AI tools critically while maintaining pedagogical intentionality.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI