Meta-analysis of the impacts of phosphorus addition on soil microbes

Soil microbes play a crucial role in myriad ecological processes in terrestrial ecosystem. With increasing nitrogen (N) loading, phosphorus (P) may become more limiting for soil microbes and these processes. However, it remains unclear to what extent P addition impacts soil microbial communities and respiration at global scale, especially under different N loadings. Therefore, we used a global meta-analysis to examine the effects of phosphorus addition on soil microbes based on 2293 paired observations from 129 studies in the world. Overall, P addition increased significantly total as well as fungal, bacterial, and actinomycete (ACT) phospholipid fatty acids (PLFAs), together with Gram+ bacteria (G+) and Gram- bacteria (G-) abundance regardless of N input or not. The increments were more pronounced under higher P addition rate or places with higher mean annual temperature or mean annual precipitation. Moreover, the fungi: bacteria ratio significantly decreased along elevational gradients. Furthermore, higher P addition frequency tended to have significantly more ACT PLFAs, as well as higher G+:G-, but significantly lower fungi: bacteria ratio (F:B). However, the responses of P addition on bacterial PLFAs and F:B were larger in forest than grassland, and cropland and varied with P fertilizer forms. In addition, the responses of soil organic carbon (SOC) contents was positively correlated with those of microbial biomass carbon (MBC) and bacterial PLFAs, and all these three parameters, in addition to fungal PLFAs, correlated positively with the response of soil respiration (Rs). Our results suggest that phosphorus addition had globally positive effects on soil microbes with different N loadings, and the positive effects of soil microbial abundance tended to promote heterotrophic respiration (Rh) and Rs. These results deepen our understanding of soil microbial community structure and function dynamics under increasing P deposition. They also provide extensive evidences and bases for parameterization of soil carbon cycling models incorporating microbial responses under global climate change.