摘要
All plant cells are surrounded by complex walls that play a role in the growth and differentiation of tissues. Walls provide mechanical integrity and structure to each cell and represent an interface with neighboring cells and the environment (Somerville et al., 2004). Cell walls are composed primarily of multiple polysaccharides that can be grouped into three major classes: cellulose, pectins, and hemicelluloses. While cellulose fibrils are synthesized by the plant cells directly at the plasma membrane (PM), the matrix polysaccharides are produced in the Golgi apparatus by membrane-bound enzymes from multiple glycosyltransferase families (Oikawa et al., 2013). After secretion to the wall via exocytosis, the structures of the noncellulosic polysaccharides are modified by various apoplastic enzymes. In addition to polysaccharides, most plant cell walls contain small amounts of structural proteins such as extensins and arabinogalactan proteins. Cell walls are dynamic entities, rather than rigid and recalcitrant shells, that can be remodeled during plant development and in response to abiotic and biotic stresses. Cell expansion requires the deposition of additional material in the surrounding primary walls as well as the reorganization and loosening of existing polymers to allow for wall relaxation and controlled expansion (Cosgrove, 2005). The latest model of the primary wall structure proposes that cellulose-cellulose junctions only occur at a limited number of biomechanical hotspots, where protein catalysts must act selectively to initiate wall loosening (Cosgrove, 2018). In tissues undergoing growth, the recycling of polysaccharides via a suite of enzymes can contribute to the construction of elongating walls (Barnes and Anderson, 2018). Once elongation ceases, some cells deposit thick secondary walls that incorporate additional polysaccharides. Many secondary walls are impregnated with the polyphenol lignin and thereby become relatively fixed structures that exclude water and resist hydrolysis. The dynamics of plant cell walls have traditionally been challenging to characterize in muro due to technical limitations and the structural complexity of their components. As an example of structural complexity, pectins can incorporate 12 different sugars in at least 25 glycosidic linkages and can be decorated further with methyl, acetyl, or phenolic groups (Atmodjo et al., 2013). While analyses of extracted carbohydrates have been instrumental for characterizing walls (Foster et al., 2010; Pettolino et al., 2012; Carpita and McCann, 2015), they do not reveal how polysaccharides are distributed across different cell layers or within a particular wall. Historically, only a few techniques were available to detect polysaccharides in living plant cells, and many of the wall-directed probes had a broad specificity and/or poorly characterized targets (Wallace and Anderson, 2012). For instance, the Calcofluor White dye has been used frequently to stain cell walls, but it fluoresces in the presence of β-glucan structures from all three major polysaccharide classes (Anderson et al., 2010). Recent technical developments, such as the identification of more specific probes, have helped elucidate the components of the plant cell wall. In this Update, we focus on current and emerging techniques for monitoring the dynamics of polysaccharides in the cell wall (Table I). We highlight recent biological insights gained from these methods, discuss the limitations of each approach, and provide a summary of specific probes that may be used to identify different polysaccharide structures in situ (Fig. 1; Table II). A summary is provided of technical advantages and limitations, along with key biological observations, which are discussed in the text. For the electron microscopy column, TEM or SEM indicate points specific to either transmission or scanning electron microscopy, respectively. R denotes the relative resolution of a technique and ranges from the diffraction limit of light (+) to atomic resolution (+++). S denotes the relative speed of a technique (including the typical sample preparation time) and ranges from multiple days (+) to mere seconds (+++). A summary is provided of technical advantages and limitations, along with key biological observations, which are discussed in the text. For the electron microscopy column, TEM or SEM indicate points specific to either transmission or scanning electron microscopy, respectively. R denotes the relative resolution of a technique and ranges from the diffraction limit of light (+) to atomic resolution (+++). S denotes the relative speed of a technique (including the typical sample preparation time) and ranges from multiple days (+) to mere seconds (+++). Major classes of probes and key steps to image cell wall polysaccharides. A, Illustration of the steps required prior to microscopy (represented by the magnifying glasses) for different types of probes. Secondary antibodies (2° mAb) are commercially available and should be selected based on the final application (electron versus light microscopy) and the available equipment (e.g. fluorescence filters). Probes in colored boxes are exemplified in B to G. B and C, Sites of wall polysaccharide synthesis in Arabidopsis cotyledons expressing the yellow FP markers wave_22Y and wave_138Y, respectively (Geldner et al., 2009). FP signal and chloroplast intrinsic fluorescence are shown using Orange Hot and Cyan Hot look-up tables in Fiji (Schindelin et al., 2012). D to G, Mucilage architecture of an S4B-stained and mAb-labeled (CCRC-M36 and Alexa Fluor 488 2° mAb) Arabidopsis seed. D shows a segment of a whole seed (black) that has been brought into contact with water. The only clearly visible structures are columellae (C). S4B staining reveals cellulosic rays in E, and the antibody CCRC-M36 shows the deposition of rhamnogalacturonan in F. The comparison of the overlay G with D exemplifies the usefulness of dyes and labels. Bars = 25 µm (B–G). Additional antibodies with known targets that are not listed here are available from PlantProbes (http://plantprobes.net) and CarboSource (https://www.ccrc.uga.edu/∼carbosource/CSS_home.html). CBMs, Carbohydrate-binding modules; Kdo, 3-deoxy-d-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid; mAb, monoclonal antibody. Additional antibodies with known targets that are not listed here are available from PlantProbes (http://plantprobes.net) and CarboSource (https://www.ccrc.uga.edu/∼carbosource/CSS_home.html). CBMs, Carbohydrate-binding modules; Kdo, 3-deoxy-d-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid; mAb, monoclonal antibody. Cellulose microfibrils are aggregates of linear β-1,4-linked glucan chains, which are stabilized by intramolecular and intermolecular hydrogen bonds in the walls (Notley et al., 2004; McNamara et al., 2015). Several types of methods have been used to visualize the microfibrils in the wall (Table I). Primary wall cellulose fibrils have been estimated to be 3 nm in diameter by spectroscopic and diffraction techniques (Thomas et al., 2013), whereas larger aggregates of microfibrils in the 5- to 10-nm-diameter range have been found in conifer wood (Fernandes et al., 2011). Even fibrils with diameters up to 40 nm were observed by electron microscopy utilizing freeze-fracture techniques (McCann et al., 1990). Currently, it is not clear how much interspersed matrix polymer material contributes to these aggregate estimates. Due to this size range, microfibrils can be observed by both atomic force microscopy and scanning electron microscopy (Zhang et al., 2016), and their angles and distances can be determined (Marga et al., 2005). Crystalline cellulose is initially oriented randomly in meristematic cells (McCann et al., 1990) but is later aligned as parallel fibrils, transverse to the axis of elongation (Sugimoto et al., 2000). The orientation of microfibrils is hypothesized to mechanically restrict the direction of cell extension, leading to anisotropic growth. Parallel cellulose microfibrils are separated during cell expansion (Marga et al., 2005), presumably yielding to internal turgor pressure and being loosened via the enzymatic modification of adjoining matrix polysaccharides (Wolf and Greiner, 2012; Cosgrove, 2016). Since microfibril diameters do not appear to decrease during the elongation process, the fibrils likely are not modified directly. In addition to cellulose found in a crystalline microfibril form, some walls are estimated to be composed of ∼40% amorphous cellulose (Marga et al., 2005). This substantial proportion of cellulose cannot be determined by the aforementioned microscopy tools and can only be estimated roughly by spectroscopic methods. CBMs are powerful probes for detecting the presence and dynamics of amorphous cellulose (McLean et al., 2002). CBMs are noncatalytic domains of carbohydrate-active enzymes and are thought to facilitate binding to specific substrates (Hall et al., 1995). Multiple cellulose-directed CBMs have been identified that bind either crystalline or amorphous structures (Table II; McLean et al., 2002). Indirect immunolabeling of plant sections with His-tagged versions of these CBMs (for a detailed mechanism, see Fig. 1A) has revealed the diversity of cellulose forms in various cell walls using fluorescence microscopy (Blake et al., 2006) or electron microscopy (Ruel et al., 2012). For example, collenchyma cells contain primary walls with a larger abundance of amorphous cellulose compared with microfibril-rich secondary walls. CBMs also provided hints about polymer interactions, as partial enzymatic removal of pectic polysaccharides in plant sections leads to a more intensive labeling of crystalline cellulose. This indicates a close spatial proximity of these two polymer classes (Blake et al., 2006) and has been demonstrated independently by solid-state NMR (Dick-Perez et al., 2012). However, certain probes may have broader specificities than expected. For instance, CBM3a is a common label for crystalline cellulose that also can bind xyloglucan (XyG), a Xyl-substituted glucan (Hernandez-Gomez et al., 2015). This issue could be mitigated by imaging walls before and after treatment with xyloglucanase or by using alternative probes (Table II). Fluorescent proteins (FPs) can be tagged to CBM domains to directly analyze polysaccharide structure without the secondary or tertiary reagents shown in Figure 1A. For instance, two fluorescently tagged CBMs enabled the dual labeling of crystalline and amorphous cellulose at the surface of plant fibers following biomass deconstruction (Gourlay et al., 2015). Such chimeric protein constructs could potentially be transformed into plants to monitor polysaccharides without any incubation steps. While in vivo fluorescent CBM probes may provide greater insights into polysaccharide dynamics in growing cells, caution is necessary. For example, the direct expression of fluorescent CBM proteins in plants would have to be tested carefully and optimized to ensure that the target polymer is visualized without altering its native architecture or plant development. Another potential disadvantage is that the FP domain may interfere with the ligand-binding site of the CBM (Knox, 2012). Regardless of the presence of FP tags, binding of a CBM or any other polysaccharide-directed mAbs provides limited quantitative information; an epitope may be found in multiple polymers, or it could be masked by its neighbors or hidden by an altered conformation of the target polysaccharide (Pattathil et al., 2015). Despite these issues, proteinaceous probes such as CBMs provide an unprecedented view of the occurrence of wall polysaccharides. Alternatively, crystalline cellulose in living cells can be fluorescently stained with S4B (Fig. 1E; Table II; available as Direct Red 23) to monitor microfibril reorientation in real time (Anderson et al., 2010). In contrast to Calcofluor White, S4B is highly specific to cellulose. Cellulose microfibrils are generated at the PM (Fig. by structures of multiple cellulose enzymes and other proteinaceous components et al., et al., is that the synthesis of glucan by the the complex the cellulose microfibrils in its et al., The estimated size of cellulose microfibrils that they are produced by a of which in the using an for electron microscopy et al., 2016). enzymes also have been visualized in the PM of living cells from the model plant Arabidopsis et al., has been used as a powerful to the speed and orientation of microfibril in this the synthesis of cellulose in secondary walls has been estimated to be than in primary walls et al., et al., et al., 2015). Since specific of the also can be visualized with mAbs or FP probes, have shown that the direction of cellulose deposition is to orientation et al., are not only in the PM but also in such as the Golgi apparatus and other small et al., 2009). could represent proteins that are in the from the where they are to the membrane of the Alternatively, the could be the of presumably for protein recycling or are to be into the PM specific such as et al., 2009). is likely a key of and where cellulose can be generated at the cell This also the major of FP probes as a for cellulose microfibril and Even can be observed in real it is not certain the proteins are cellulose. This may be by monitoring cellulose deposition with probes, at the A of CBM3a and S4B staining in Arabidopsis revealed that cellulose is at the cell than thought et al., are not at the of elongating where S4B and CBM3a are et al., 2011). other proteins are likely to be for the of these et al., and probes are to further characterize their structures and to identify how they are In contrast to the linear cellulose polymers, matrix polysaccharides as pectins and can be and and are thought to be synthesized in the Golgi (Fig. Once to the matrix polysaccharides are modified by various apoplastic and are complex polysaccharides that are in (Atmodjo et al., 2013), such as rhamnogalacturonan and and matrix polysaccharides that can be extracted using only as a and and In contrast to the current for in the mAbs and FP probes indicate that are at the PM et al., 2015). the of matrix polysaccharides and their in the wall are only to be The architecture of matrix polysaccharides has been revealed by the development of methods (Table and the identification of probes with specific target (Table II). is the most in primary walls and can be modified in via and other major pectic and contain and are by (Atmodjo et al., 2013). The Arabidopsis more than enzymes et al., the of only a few have been characterized to in various and is controlled by and at least et al., 2015). with altered expression of these have been characterized using mAbs domains with different of mAbs (e.g. and Table bind or whereas other mAbs (e.g. and Table these probes has been instrumental in the of in cell walls. with transmission electron microscopy revealed that is synthesized in the plant Golgi apparatus in a highly by whereas are without (Zhang and After deposition in the can be by in a specific that in of two et al., 2015). of can be via to wall or by enzymes (e.g. to wall The of on cell wall architecture can be in the that Arabidopsis (Fig. This cell wall more than and only amounts of cellulose and et al., of can be with the CCRC-M36 (Fig. Table or visualized with (Table a dye that selectively to such as and is with both light and electron microscopy and The dye a for Arabidopsis et al., and a number of Arabidopsis with altered architecture et al., 2016). The presence of which can be by the size of For instance, in due to a of and an abundance of boxes with the et al., 2013). The addition of further the of to with the model that can In the wall architecture of the by with et al., that the to facilitate the loosening of matrix polysaccharides. with the have been observed for two additional in et al., and et al., 2013). While the via protein in the and directly in the matrix where is a model for the role of in cell expansion that pectins are not as in as thought et al., The of boxes in cell walls may have been by certain immunolabeling the to caution using these powerful For instance, immunolabeling of requires the addition of and at that are greater than et al., the of on cell walls also should be with other force microscopy (Table has been used to the of walls in living of Arabidopsis plants as well as in a or an et al., 2011). While the model that the of the pectic the atomic force microscopy found that of wall loosening and a for et al., 2011). in growing cells is likely by enzymes such as the identified in cell expansion and which are required for the development of multiple Arabidopsis et al., et al., While the structure is visualized using these relatively probes may have limited and multiple incubation steps that for imaging of dynamics (Fig. Probes with have for monitoring is a stain that with to bind to used at imaging in Arabidopsis and without altering cell growth et al., 2011). with of growing at cell wall that et al., Alternatively, can be in real time with fluorescently tagged (Table and the specificity of this labeling tested using et al., of probes to two revealed how cells in Arabidopsis only of used to monitor the of in elongating et al., growth, only of the with the of proteins et al., and the probes can label in than to provide an unprecedented resolution of dynamics in living dynamics were visualized using with Alexa Fluor 488 and probes in cells or the et al., and only of the they both an the presence of and and were more for in three compared with labeling of fixed cells with mAbs and et al., these probes are to mAbs and should be the of to image polymers in and modified sugars can be into plant cell walls to visualize dynamics (Anderson and 2012). is of wall Arabidopsis were shown to primarily incorporate an into a pectic polymer that is most likely (Anderson et al., 2012). Since the can be fluorescently with a (Fig. it can be used to identify proteins required to the of to the cell wall. This that elongating cells the incorporate and in an compared with the et al., 2015). In the synthesis and of pectic polymer can be visualized using a of Kdo, a to et al., 2016). The is with other probes (e.g. the to image multiple matrix polysaccharides during growth. The and probes have been via which are to Arabidopsis and may the wall. However, two alternative methods to detect not were and could be used to the dynamics of et al., 2016). is a matrix polysaccharide in plants and the most in the primary wall and 2016). Since cellulose it thought that this forms the major structure in growing cells and that its a major role in cell However, the Arabidopsis only and growth et al., the role of in growth. plants et al., that an role in growth. The of can on the plant et al., However, recent analyses revealed that structures can be specific et al., et al., et al., 2015). on analyses of plant is found in many but not in plant tissues from of the and the alternative to identify at the is the of the (Table which the wall-directed with a characterized epitope specificity et al., by has been visualized in tissues in the and in the of et al., and et al., 2013), and in of et al., 2015). The presence of this particular of in tissues that its structure and/or are for growth or at the interface the plant and the the role of in cell microscopy of cell walls and Anderson, 2016). cell walls are of expansion during and of S4B-stained cellulose. in as well as of proteins during and Anderson, 2016). While the cellulose structure visualized with two tools dye and the dynamics of polymers as and close have to be The development of specific probes with microscopy is for monitoring the structure of in dynamic such as have been used to visualize enzymes that act in elongating walls of cells in Arabidopsis and cells et al., 2005). Since fluorescently into the cell this could be in other biological In multiple or of and have been synthesized as potential for et al., 2016), but of were into Arabidopsis found a that is at this with growth, and leads to et al., 2016). are available to label hemicelluloses. Even most of the wall is in et al., an only (Anderson et al., 2012). the is not to the as a et al., et al., 2016), the highlight of the current limitations of using or other to monitor wall with different the from wall polymer enzymes. and are the two major classes of that in plant secondary walls and and have composed primarily of and respectively. The dynamics of have to be in insights into their structural were gained in recent et al., et al., probes are available (e.g. and Table but they cannot bind forms of and are not to the presence of in the polymer et al., which in A major of these proteinaceous probes is that their to target can be masked by pectic et al., 2010). the could be prior to it would be to probes that these In the tools for dynamics have been The synthesis of various has enabled the of mAbs et al., 2015). While with plant polysaccharides et al., or et al., have been with mAbs (Pattathil et al., of have an and facilitate the of the by probes. A of wall-directed mAbs identified specific for probes that were et al., This also the of a few mAbs that were characterized in (Table such as the specificity of for with et al., 2015). Since specific mAbs are available for et al., the current must be to detect the diversity of structures found in For instance, also can be directly using Table as a for monitoring polymers during biomass et al., but also could be used in the of probes and to greater into polymer interactions, solid-state NMR has as a powerful technique to monitor the architecture of the plant cell wall. were found to have a conformation and were to cellulose microfibrils in Arabidopsis but not in a et al., 2016). solid-state NMR revealed that an of is for to bind to cellulose in the conformation et al., The role of these also is by and dynamics of et al., The of also can be observed using an emerging technique that specific to in polysaccharide and this used only to the and of and during in et al., However, can detect all major classes of cell wall polysaccharides et al., and used to for Arabidopsis with altered structures et al., et al., and et al., 2015). with microscopy the to the wall structural resolution to the and image the dynamics of multiple polysaccharides in This be for detecting wall polymers (e.g. that cannot be with existing probes (Table II). techniques to monitor polysaccharides (Table along with the of the have an of to the of plant cell wall synthesis and Many in these have been However, the and of wall polymer synthesis and the of polymer and the dynamics of wall during cell growth and differentiation a The identification and of probes, with light on these Even probes (e.g. S4B and Table can be visualized with by plant tissues using techniques that and and steps et al., 2018). the resolution of limited by diffraction to greater than nm this has been in the to the imaging of living plant cells at the et al., 2018). the of fluorescence microscopy, probes such as S4B can potentially be visualized in the walls of living plant cells at a resolution more methods such as atomic force microscopy and electron microscopy (Table et al., 2013). membrane probes can reveal the dynamics of at a spatial resolution of and of of of seconds for probes et al., in situ imaging of plant cell wall polysaccharides would be and could be by further in techniques such as components of the wall not in this Update, such as lignin and structural could or have been using has been a time to the dynamics of a range of plant cell wall