麦克内马尔试验
医学
基线(sea)
前瞻性队列研究
急诊科
可靠性(半导体)
医疗急救
急诊医学
灵敏度(控制系统)
人工智能
医学物理学
软件部署
物理疗法
诊断准确性
诊断试验
临床实习
梅德林
作者
Jin Rong Tan,Anh Nguyen Tuan Tran,Wei Yow Sim,Jia Rong Jonathan Mok,Felicia Hui Min Thng,Jason Hong Seng Toh,May San Mak,Siew Kune Wong,Meng Ai Png
标识
DOI:10.1038/s41746-026-03313-x
摘要
Artificial intelligence (AI) systems for fracture detection perform strongly in controlled settings, but prospective real-world evidence is limited. In a three-month deployment in one emergency department, thirteen radiographers in a radiographer-led screening programme independently interpreted 2496 consecutive musculoskeletal examinations (one radiographer per examination), reviewed output from a commercial deep-learning system, then recorded a final decision, giving 2496 paired reads against a radiologist reference standard. Standalone AI sensitivity was 75.6%, falling to 46.2% for subtle fractures, below the radiographers’ baseline sensitivity of 91.6%. Radiographers’ baseline accuracy was high (97.6%; specificity 99.0%) and improved modestly with AI assistance (98.0%; exact McNemar p = 0.0064). With AI assistance, radiographers corrected 11 errors and introduced 1, a net gain of 10 cases. Subgroup gains were directionally consistent but not significant after correction. Radiographers changed their decision in only 11 of 729 discordant cases, and most negative interactions were correct AI recommendations not adopted. No or incomplete AI output was returned for 8.8% of acquired examinations. AI assistance delivered a small, selective benefit arising from complementary rather than superior algorithmic performance. Operational reliability proved as consequential as diagnostic accuracy, and behavioural inferences rest on few events. Downstream clinical outcomes were not measured.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI