Building on the premise that performance shortfall influences firms to engage in problemistic search, this study suggests that emerging economy firms prefer technology catchup to R&D search as a behavioral response to performance shortfall. In addition, this study theorizes that policy instruments referred to in the national innovation policies that enable R&D focus managerial attention towards R&D search and away from technology catchup. Hence while they weaken the relationship between performance shortfall and technology catchup, they strengthen the association between performance shortfall and R&D search. I test and find empirical support for my predictions on a sample of Indian manufacturing firms from 1992 to 2018 and perform several additional tests which further support my predictions. This study advances research on the direction of technology search, the problemistic search behaviors of emerging economy firms, and the important role played by innovation policies and institutions in shaping problemistic search direction.