Stratification of Patients with Renal Cell Carcinoma by the Abundance of Sarcomatoid Features Reveals Differences in Survival and the Underlying Pathobiology

Abstract

Sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma (sRCC) is histologically heterogeneous, with variable sarcomatoid amounts intermixed within epithelial carcinoma. However, the current classification for this aggressive disease is homogeneous and agnostic to the sarcomatoid proportion. We investigated whether sRCC subclassification has prognostic value and can reveal the biology underlying dedifferentiation and its clinical aggressiveness. On the basis of the intratumoral abundance of sarcomatoid features, cases were classified as sarcomatoid-high (≥10% sarcomatoid features) or sarcomatoid-low (<10% sarcomatoid features) in a cohort of 104 consecutive patients with sRCC undergoing nephrectomy at a single center. In comparison to sarcomatoid-low patients (n = 52), sarcomatoid-high patients (n = 52) had significantly shorter overall survival (median 14.5 vs 62.9 mo; p < 0.001), which was confirmed on multivariable analysis, and significantly shorter median metastasis-free survival among patients with clinically localized disease (10.7 vs 39.0 mo; p = 0.043). Transcriptomic analyses of 45 sRCC tumors revealed significant upregulation of nine hallmark pathways related to cell cycle/proliferation, epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition, reactive oxidative species, and interferon-α signaling among sarcomatoid-high (n = 24) versus sarcomatoid-low (n = 21) tumors. Categorization into transcriptomic clusters revealed predominance of proliferative, inflammatory, and immune effector phenotypes among sarcomatoid-high tumors, versus a hypoxia/angiogenesis phenotype among sarcomatoid-low tumors. Overall, these findings indicate prognostic value for sRCC subclassification into high versus low sarcomatoid groups and highlight key biology underlying the differences in clinical outcomes.

Patient summary

Sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma (sRCC) is a highly aggressive form of kidney cancer. The percentage of sarcomatoid features varies among tumors, but sRCC is still defined as a single kidney cancer type. Our results show that grouping patients according to their percentage of sarcomatoid features improves prediction of whether their tumors will become metastatic or lethal, and reveal molecular differences that may be important for this disease. Future assignment of sRCC to high and low sarcomatoid groups may help in guiding research and patient management.