Platform scholars tend to focus on how dominant firms design and lead a single platform that participating firms leverage. Often, the platform sponsor controls the technical architecture, rules of engagement and business model. However, platforms are more dynamic than is generally recognized and often change their control parameters. How do participating firms adapt their strategy when a platform transitions from proprietary to collective control? We examine how participating firms make strategic choices on how to engage with a common platform as control evolves from proprietary to collective control. With field data from a platform founder and 16 participating firms, we examined how firms with both competitive and collaborative orientations responded differently to the emergence of collective control. Although scholars tend to assume that only complementors contribute to platforms, our research shows that competitors do so as well although for different reasons. While neither complementors nor competitors changed their competitive orientation as the platform transitioned to collective control, they both adapted their intensity of engagement with the platform. We show how these patterns affect the vitality of the platform’s ecosystem. Our research explains how both sponsoring and participating firms adapt to collective control and shows how firms guardedly learn to collaborate in ways that both preserve and threaten their competitive advantage.