A Comparative Study of Outdoor Thermal Comfort in Centralized Traditional Organic and Modern Standardized Rural Settlements

Global warming has significantly intensified the risks of summer heatwaves, making outdoor thermal comfort during extreme heat periods a critical research focus. Under centralized rural village reconstruction policies, traditional settlements are being replaced by regularized modern communities characterized by new materials and standardized layouts. However, the impact of these morphological transitions on the micro-scale thermal environment remains under-researched, with a notable lack of comparative perspectives between traditional organic and modern standardized typologies. This study identifies six representative zones based on spatial configuration. By integrating UAV photogrammetry (Pix4Dmapper v4.5), AutoCAD 2019, and QGIS (v3.22), morphological characteristics were quantified, followed by microclimate simulations using ENVI-met v5.9. The results reveal that while peak daytime Physiological Equivalent Temperature (PET) in the standardized zones (49.2–51.8 °C) is slightly lower than in traditional zones (53.5–55.2 °C), a phenomenon of thermal homogenization emerges in the former. Specifically, values in standardized zones are highly concentrated around the median (53.5 °C), contributing to a significant upward trend in the minimum PET values, with nearly all sampling points exceeding 47.0 °C. Quantitative analysis identifies green coverage and perviousness as primary cooling drivers, while spatial openness and imperviousness promote thermal homogenization. In contrast, traditional zones retain critical cool refuges due to their spatial heterogeneity. This research provides an empirical foundation and quantitative reference for understanding the thermal performance differences across different rural spatial typologies. The findings offer insights for planners to optimize street layouts and shading strategies, ultimately mitigating heat stress and fostering climate-resilient modern countryside development.