Abstract Future practical applications of the electrochemical CO 2 reduction reaction will probably involve the use of higher pressures and temperatures. However, most research on the copper-catalysed electrochemical CO 2 reduction reaction—the most widely studied system due to its C–C coupling ability—is typically performed under ambient conditions, and hence the mechanistic conclusions drawn also pertain to those conditions. Using a custom high-pressure, high-temperature electrochemical cell, we show here that on copper electrodes, the C–C coupling mechanism changes from the typical CO dimerization mechanism at low temperatures to a Fischer–Tropsch-like chain growth mechanism at temperatures above 125 °C (also requiring higher pressure). These results show that temperature and pressure are crucial parameters to consider in applied and mechanistic studies of the electrochemical reduction of CO 2 because they can open up alternative reaction pathways and alter known mechanisms.