Introducing automation intends to yield performance benefits, increase system safety and efficiency, and decrease costs. However, the intended benefits are often offset by negative effects such as complacency and automation bias, loss of situation awareness, and skill degradation. Automating systems is not an all-or-none decision, and degree of automation (DOA) has been shown to influence both intended performance benefits as well as performance decrements. While performance benefits more from higher automation, results about the optimal degree of automation in terms of preventing negative effects are not so clear-cut. In a first study, we investigated effects of degree of automation on routine performance and failure performance using a simulated process control task. Results show that primary and secondary task performance as well as workload benefit from providing automation, and performance gains were higher for higher DOA. However, skill degradation was observed for the highest DOA when returning to manual performance. Regarding automation bias, there was no effect of DOA. The second study focused on the effects of system experience. Failure experience led to a strong decrease in trust, also reflected in more intense automation verification. Early failure experience reduced the risk of complacency and automation bias but did not prevent it completely. Moreover, we identified three possible causes of commission errors: a) incomplete automation verification, b) complete automation verification without attentive processing of contradictory information, analogous to a “looking-but-not-seeing” effect, c) discounting of contradictory system information. The third study looked into effects of operator functional state and DOA. Higher DOA could better protect performance after extended wakefulness, but return-to-manual performance suffered more. More information was sampled for automation verification during the night, and the risk of commission errors was lower compared to daytime performance.