<p>Electrobiocorrosion (i.e. direct metal-to-microbe electron transfer) is a recently recognized, highly aggressive form of microbial metal corrosion. <i>Methanobacterium subterraneum</i> strain YSL grows as an electron accepting partner in direct interspecies electron transfer, suggesting that it might have the capacity for electrobiocorrosion. To evaluate this possibility, strain YSL was grown with either pure Fe<sup>0</sup>, which abiotically generates H<sub>2</sub>, or 316L stainless steel, which does not generate H<sub>2</sub>, as the sole potential electron donor. There was a steady accumulation of H<sub>2</sub> in uninoculated controls with Fe<sup>0</sup>. No H<sub>2</sub> was detected in strain YSL cultures with Fe<sup>0</sup>. Rather, strain YSL produced methane at a rate consistent with conversion of the H<sub>2</sub> abiotically generated from Fe<sup>0</sup> to methane. Strain YSL did not produce methane in incubations with stainless steel. These results indicated that strain YSL relies on H<sub>2</sub> as an intermediary electron carrier between Fe<sup>0</sup> and cells, a result in conflict with the previous report that strain YSL was incapable of H<sub>2</sub> utilization. Further investigation revealed that strain YSL can grow on H<sub>2</sub>, but more than 50-fold slower than is typical for other <i>Methanobacterium</i> strains. Genomic analysis revealed that mutations in genes for seven subunits of Eha, the primary energy-converting hydrogenase of <i>Methanobacterium</i> species, likely disabled its function in strain YSL. Proteomic analysis suggested that a compensatory high expression of cytoplasmic hydrogenases enabled slow growth on H<sub>2</sub>. These studies highlight the importance of analyzing slow metabolic capabilities, which are difficult to detect with standard methods yet can have significant environmental consequences.</p>