This study was concerned with why amplitude modulation of nontarget components disrupts profile analysis. The 1-kHz target component was unmodulated whereas the nontarget components were unmodulated or sinusoidally amplitude modulated at a rate of 10 Hz. In experiment 1, thresholds were measured as a function of the modulation depth of the nontarget components for four different targets: One consisted of a long-duration tone and three consisted of multiple short-duration tones located at the peaks, valleys, or leading edges of the modulation cycles of the nontarget components. Although there were differences across the three subjects, thresholds typically increased with increasing modulation depth for all four targets, indicating that restricting profile analysis to particular points in the modulation cycle does not alleviate the effect of amplitude modulation. In experiment 2, the signal consisted of multiple short-duration tones; the nontarget components were unmodulated and presented at levels below or above the level of the target component (i.e., positive and negative pedestals were created). Although thresholds generally were worse when the target and nontarget components were unequal in level than when they were equal, the results suggest that this pedestal effect cannot account entirely for the effect of amplitude modulation on profile analysis. This conclusion was further substantiated by a supplemental experiment that used square-wave modulation. For the single subject tested, thresholds increased as modulation depth increased, regardless of whether or not the target and nontarget components were equal in level at the time of signal occurrence.