This study investigated the mediation and moderation process through which openness to diversity influences team creativity. Data were collected in three waves from two sources (supervisors and their subordinates) in 87 teams in China. Results suggest that leader intellectual stimulation moderated the direct effect of openness to diversity on constructive criticism, and further the indirect effect of openness to diversity on team creativity via constructive criticism. These direct and indirect effects were stronger when leader intellectual stimulation was higher. We controlled for knowledge sharing as a parallel mediating mechanism to demonstrate the unique mediating role of constructive criticism in the analysis. The study sheds light on the impact of openness to diversity and adds values to the diversity theory.