Comparison of the influence of supportive and sensorimotor insoles in the muscle activity of tibialis anterior and peroneus longus in combat boots

Flatfoot is a very common static deformity. It occurs frequently in soldiers and causes problems in the lower extremities. There is a lack of data regarding therapy with insoles, especially with sensorimotor insoles. The objective of this study was to investigate the influence in muscle activity of supporting/correcting and sensorimotor insoles in combat boots in the muscles of the lower limb and thus to draw conclusions according to the benefits of insole therapy in military footwear. 73 patients (12 female, 61 males; average age: 30.8 ± 7.9 years) with pes planovalgus deformity were included in this prospective randomized placebo-controlled study. For intervention supporting (N = 23), sensorimotor (N = 28) and placebo insoles (N = 22) were used. During gait analysis muscle activity was measured by means of surface electromyography (EMG) of the tibialis anterior and peroneus longus muscle in combat boots with and without insoles. Statistical evaluation was performed using two-factor ANOVA with repeated measures. EMG measures (amplitude, integral, maximum, mean) showed mainly activating effects in the peroneus longus muscle in the case of sensorimotor and activity reductions in supporting insoles. Comparing effects of different kinds of insoles to the peroneus longus muscle, significant differences could be shown. No significant differences in muscular activation were observed for the tibialis anterior muscle. Even in combat boots effects of sensorimotor insoles on the peroneus longus muscle can be detected. The expected effects, attributed to the different kinds of insole, could be observed, too. While sensorimotor insoles had an activating kind of effect, supportive insoles reduced muscular activity of the peroneus longus. In contrast for the tibialis anterior muscle no clear conclusion could be drawn. Its muscular activity seems not to be influenced by insoles in combat boots. However, it remains unclear whether clinical long term effects, e.g. pain and function, can be improved.