Features of interactions responsible for antifungal activity against resistant type cytochrome bc1: A data-driven analysis based on the binding free energy at the atomic level

Quinone outside inhibitors (QoIs), which inhibit the mitochondrial respiratory system by binding to the Qo site of Complex III in fungi, are widely used as pesticides with broad spectrum antifungal activity. However, excessive use of QoIs leads to pesticide resistance through mutation of amino acid residues in the Qo site. Recently, metyltetraprole, a novel QoI that is effective against wild-type and resistant mutant fungi, was developed. Interestingly, metyltetraprole has a very similar structure to other QoIs, azoxystrobin and pyraclostrobin, which do not act on resistant mutants. However, it is unknown how slight structural differences in these inhibitors alter their effectiveness towards fungi with amino acid mutations in the Qo site of Complex III. Therefore, we studied the features of interactions of inhibitors effective towards resistant mutants by quantitatively comparing the interaction profiles of three QoIs at the atomic level. First, we reproduced the binding affinity by the thermodynamic integration (TI) method, which treated explicitly environmental molecules and considered the pseudo-binding pathway. As such, a good correlation (R2 = 0.74) was observed between the binding free energy calculated using the TI method and experimentally observed pIC50 value in 12 inhibitor-target pairs, including wild-type and mutant Complex III in two fungal species, Zymoseptoria tritici and Pyrenophora teres. Trajectory analysis of this TI calculation revealed that the effectiveness against resistant mutant fungi strongly depended on the interaction of constituent parts of the inhibitor disposed near the active center of the target protein. Specifically, the key in the effectiveness against resistant mutant fungi is that the corresponding component part, tetrazolinone moiety of metyltetraprole, traded off Coulomb and van der Waals interactions in response to subtle changes in the binding pose.