Aboveground net primary productivity and soil respiration display different responses to precipitation changes in desert grassland

Abstract Precipitation (PPT) changes affect both aboveground vegetation dynamics and belowground carbon cycling processes, particularly in arid and semiarid regions. However, it remains unclear how extreme PPT variation can affect soil carbon sequestration potential. A 3-year PPT manipulation experiment with five levels (±40%, ±20% and ambient PPT) was conducted in a desert grassland of western Loess Plateau. Aboveground net primary productivity (ANPP) and soil respiration (Rs) were measured to examine whether the responses of ANPP and Rs to PPT changes displayed a double asymmetry model. The ANPP was more sensitive to extreme drought than extreme wet treatments in wet and dry years, which displayed a negative asymmetric model. The change in ANPP was mainly due to the direct effect of PPT change, and plant density variation also exerted some influence in the dry year. In contrast, Rs displayed a positive asymmetry response to PPT change in dry year. This may be ascribed to enhanced autotrophic respiration due to the enhanced positive responses of plant growth and ANPP to wet treatments as well as stronger birch effect of rainfall events on heterotrophic respiration. The saturating response of Rs to extreme drought (−40% PPT treatment) was also found in the dry year. Nevertheless, the response of Rs to PPT change displayed a negative asymmetry model in wet years. The contrasting models for ANPP and Rs in response to altered PPT regime suggest that extreme wet or dry treatments may increase soil C pools effluxes toward debt in this desert grassland.