Comparative Analysis of Deep Generative Model for Industrial Enzyme Design

Although enzymes have the advantage of efficient catalysis, natural enzymes lack stability in industrial environments and do not even meet the required catalytic reactions. This prompted us to urgently <i>de novo</i> design new enzymes. As a powerful strategy, computational method can not only explore sequence space rapidly and efficiently, but also promote the design of new enzymes suitable for specific conditions and requirements, so it is very beneficial to design new industrial enzymes. Currently, there exists only one tool for enzyme generation, which exhibits suboptimal performance. We have selected several general protein sequence design tools and systematically evaluated their effectiveness when applied to specific industrial enzymes. We summarized the computational methods used for protein sequence generation into three categories: structure-conditional sequence generation, sequence generation without structural constraints, and co-generation of sequence and structure. To effectively evaluate the ability of the six computational tools to generate enzyme sequences, we first constructed a luciferase dataset named Luc_64. Then we assessed the quality of enzyme sequences generated by these methods on this dataset, including amino acid distribution, EC number validation, etc. We also assessed sequences generated by structure-based methods on existing public datasets using sequence recovery rates and root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) from a sequence and structure perspective. In the functionality dataset, Luc_64, ABACUSR and ProteinMPNN stood out for producing sequences with amino acid distributions and functionalities closely matching those of naturally occurring luciferase enzymes, suggesting their effectiveness in preserving essential enzymatic characteristics. Across both benchmark datasets, ABACUS-R and ProteinMPNN, have also exhibited the highest sequence recovery rates, indicating their superior ability to generate sequences closely resembling the original enzyme structures. Our study provides a crucial reference for researchers selecting appropriate enzyme sequence design tools, highlighting the strengths and limitations of each tool in generating accurate and functional enzyme sequences. ProteinMPNN and ABACUS-R emerged as the most effective tools in our evaluation, offering high accuracy in sequence recovery and RMSD and maintaining the functional integrity of enzymes through accurate amino acid distribution. Meanwhile, the performance of protein general tools for migration to specific industrial enzymes was fairly evaluated on our specific industrial enzyme benchmark.